The Grammys, unlike the usually more-or-less accurately forecasted Oscars, are always full of surprises, this year hardly being any exception. Jon Batiste receiving a leading five wins? Who saw that coming — except for anyone who saw him coming in with a leading 11 nominations and figured the math might translate?But that arithmetic did not carry over for the highly nominated Billie Eilish and Lil Nas X, who went home empty-handed (but still full-hearted, let’s hope), or produce the results quite expected for Olivia Rodrigo and the Tony Bennett/Lady Gaga teaming.
Meanwhile, during the pre-telecast Premiere Ceremony presentation, live-streamed on the Recording Academy’s YouTube channel, there were other kind of surprises including some seemingly honest confusion about given names and gender involving best new artist nominee and pre-telecast presenter Arlo Parks and veteran bluegrass picker (and pre-telecast winner) Bela Fleck. After all, the Grammys are one very, very long day for all involved.
Here’s a rundown of this year’s biggest snubs and surprises:
SURPRISE: Silk Sonic sweeps
The duo of Bruno Mars and Anderson. Paak had the only perfect record of the night, at least among nominees with a significant number of turns at bat. “We are really trying our hardest to remain humble at this point,” said .Paak, “but in the industry we call that a clean sweep.”
They won in all four categories in which they were nominated: record of the year, song of the year, best R&B song and best R&B performance. If they’d been up for album of the year (Silk Sonic’s collection won’t be eligible till next year, because it came out after the Oct. 1 cutoff), they probably would have gotten that one, too. So anyone who would prefer to see the love thrown around a little can be grateful for small favors, and that Silk Sonic will have some different categories to dominate in 2023. In retrospect, Silk Sonic being Grammy bait shouldn’t have been as big a surprise as it was, given the way Bruno Mars swept with six wins when he was last up as a solo artist four years ago. (As a footnote, though, Silk Sonic did within one single vote of not getting that clean sweep, as the duo tied for R&B performance with Jazmine Sullivan.)
SNUB: No presenter calls Lil Nas X by his name
“Can’t believe I lost all my Grammys,” wrote the hip-hop artist on Twitter. “I am now no longer gay!” Here’s a man who not only doesn’t avoid the subject of his losses, he leans into it. Of course, he still has his “Old Town Road” victories from two years ago to keep him warm. But any thought that Nas would be rewarded for coming out as boldly as he did were quickly set aside.
Even if he was never the leading candidate to win album or record of the year, how does he lose for music video when he had the water-cooler clip of the year with “Montero (Call Me By Your Name)”? That’s easy: He loses when that video stands in the way of the Recording Academy and its love affair with Jon Batiste.
SURPRISE: Jon Batiste is the popular kid
Batiste didn’t “sweep” like Silk Sonic did. Even so, in winning less than half the categories he was up for, he was still the biggest winner of the night, because he came in with an astonishing 11 nominations and prevailed with five of those. That included the album of the year prize as well as some subcategories, like two wins for American roots, where he won over some performers who are far more associated with that genre.
“The creative arts are subjective,” he said in giving an acceptance speech for album of the year. And the Academy subjectively gave him a big, wet kiss. It was always a possibility Batiste would do this well, though. In his night job as band leader for Stephen Colbert, he’s worked directly with a large number of Academy voters and their teams, with positive interactions. He’s a symbol of genre agnosticism, despite his jazz chops. “We Are” is nothing if not the feel-good album of the year, even for a lot of jazz-haters who just dig his R&B-pop chops. And, as Brandi Carlile told PvNew on a red carpet this week (after collaborating with him on leadership of MusicCares’ Joni Mitchell tribute), “I loved working with Jon — he’s a true abstract, a true avant-garde and an absolute genius. He’s our generation’s Herbie Hancock.”
SNUB: Olivia Rodrigo is not this year’s Billie Eilish after all
As a teenager, Rodrigo should be thrilled by her three Grammys her first time out, and probably is. She was foreordained to win best new artist; no one lost their Grammy lottery by getting that one wrong. That’s phenomenal, right? So calling this a “snub” may be a misnomer… except for the over-heightened expectations of just how much the commercial and critical phenomenon of her success might translate to a clean sweep of the top four categories, a la Eilish did two years ago. But in the end, “Drivers License” did not prevail in record or song as widely predicted. Again, who would have guessed that a voting bloc still largely made up of thousands of middle-aged guys would not clutch a song about passing driver’s ed to their collective bosom?
SURPRISE: Voters haven’t canceled Louis C.K., and are surprisingly unafraid to admit it
After four years of being embattled for sexual misconduct allegations that would have killed many another career, Louis C.K. is seemingly A-OK with the Academy and won for best comedy recording. Many will see this as voters turning a blind eye to one of the most flagrant examples of #MeToo the industry has seen… and as giving the Academy a black eye in turn.
SNUB: BTS and Justin Bieber are pop bridesmaids again
If they gave an award for “most phenomenal performance on the Grammys,” the K-pop group would be up for it in 2023. But in lieu of anything like that, the seven members probably don’t care about losing out on a lone nomination again nearly as much as its massive fan base known as ARMY does. Bowling over a mass TV audience like they did Sunday night is its own reward.
But maybe Bieber is not as sanguine about going home empty-handed, as he and his team are known to have taken the Grammys seriously in the past. The institution certainly takes him a lot more seriously than it used to; he was up for seven awards this year (and tied for that amount with Doja Cat and H.E.R.), second only to Batiste’s 11. Truth be told, Bieber wasn’t forecasted to win in any of the major categories; “Justice” was as strong an album as he’s ever made, but his primary competitors just had more interesting stories coming into the voting. Still, it’s gotta sting.
SNUB: No back-to-back Oscar/Grammy combo for Billie
We’re going to go out on a limb here and guess that, even going 0-for-7, Billie Eilish doesn’t really care that she was shut out at the 2022 Grammys, after dominating the 2020 awards, after winning record of the year in 2021, and after just receiving an Oscar last week. Not to underestimate anyone’s capacity for disappointment, but Eilish seems so grounded, and has been so rewarded, the phrase “happier than ever” might even still apply this week.
SURPRISE: A bigger look for country music on the show than in the nominations
Country music got a big snub when the nominations came out in November: Out of 40 possible nominations the genre could pick up in the top four general categories, country claimed only one — a nomination for Jimmie Allen as best new artist, which he was destined to lose to Rodrigo. But watching the show, it was curious that the climactic moments were reserved for Carrie Underwood (who premiered a new single) and, finally, Brothers Osborne. Maybe this was the network’s way of reminding us that it is hosting the CMT Music Awards for the first time, in just eight days.
Regardless, it was a hell of a good night for Brothers Osborne, and not just because of that finale slot. Winning for country group/duo performance during the pre-telecast, singer TJ Osborne gave an emotional speech about how their winning song “Younger Me” was born out of his experience coming out as gay in 2021. At the recent ACM Awards (also in Las Vegas), the brothers talked backstage about how their country radio airplay has been on the downswing, without blaming it on any one factor. But their optics were in winning form at the Grammys.
SURPRISE: Misgendering during the pre-telecast
There were a couple of awkward slips regarding gender during the long Premiere Awards pre-telecast presentation. Host LeVar Burton introduced female presenter Arlo Parks, a nominee for new artist and alternative album, as “a Gen Z artist from London that is blurring the boundaries of music with a brave new artist and lyrics that are immersed in his own personal experience.” Not much later, ironically, as a presenter, Parks did he same thing to another artist, accepting an award on behalf of male bluegrass veteran Béla Fleck as “on her behalf.” (Asked later about the gender mixups, Parks told PvNew: “It is what it is.”)
SNUB: Tony Bennett doesn’t get quite as rewarding a career sendoff as expected
There was a lot of prognosticating that Bennett’s swan-song recording, in combination with Lady Gaga, would win album of the year as a sentimental favorite in honor of the 95-year-old’s entire career. In the end, voters might have decided that his winning that honor in the mid-’90s for “MTV Unplugged” was sufficient in giving him a late-career position on the top Grammy rolls.
Anyway, Gaga’s salute to the Alzheimer’s-stricken Bennett (who briefly introduced her via video) was better than any award could have been. If you weren’t touched by her final gesture, to put her own hand on her shoulder where his had been in the overhead picture, you might never have had a heart to leave in San Francisco anyway.
Still, you have to wonder if Grammy producers themselves expected the Gaga/Bennett project to win album of the year. Everyone would have loved to see Gaga give a heartfelt speech in honor of her destined-to-be-forever-absent collaborator… and the place to ensure that would happen would have been by giving best traditional pop album a spot on the telecast. When that category was relegated to the pre-telecast, it was if the Grammys were signaling: Don’t worry, she’ll get her shot at the end of the show. But Batiste’s momentum ensured that was not to be.
SURPRISE: Jazmine Sullivan gets her due in R&B categories
OK, it shouldn’t be wholly surprising that the woman many are considering the current or next queen of R&B should fare well. After all, PvNew‘s own predictions said that Sullivan would get best R&B album. But it was still widely considered an upset when she prevailed in that category over H.E.R., Leon Bridges and the seemingly indomitable Batiste, and maybe just a little less so when she tied with Silk Sonic for R&B performance. It feels almost inevitable that she’ll move up to a spot as a nominee in the top general categories her next time around.
SNUB: Less famous but arguably more deserving candidates in other genre categories
It certainly didn’t go down in the country, Americana and American roots categories like it did in R&B. When Jazmine Sullivan beat some bigger names in her division, it felt like the exception to a rule. That rule was felt when Chris Stapleton added three more Grammys to his pile; although any Stapleton win can hardly be counted as a crime, it felt rote when a Mickey Guyton is being denied her shot.
Things didn’t go any better for the Black women of Nashville (recently collectively profiled in PvNew) in the American roots categories. Batiste prevailed in two of those, even though he has never been considered part of that community. Of course, the Grammys are obligated to follow any rules about who is Americana and who’s not, and there’s a fine argument to be made that Batiste is. But that neither Yola nor Allison Russell (whose album was named best of the year by PvNew and second-best by the New York Times) could get in a win among their multiple nominations is just quizzical, unless they split the vote, or unless members were just voting across the ballot for Batiste. Similarly, a win for Los Lobos on a covers album even they admitted wasn’t a passion project felt anticlimactic. At least Rhiannon Giddens won for folk album — possibly by virtue of there being no more famous person in the category.
SNUB: Kanye West can add to his list of reasons to beef with the Grammys
Ye was not completely shut out, mind you. He won best melodic rap performance for “Hurricane” and best rap song for “Jail.” But the fact that he lost out for even best rap album for “Donda” (to Tyler, the Creator), let alone album of the year, bordered on feeling like a statement — particularly when the album had more than 70 co-nominees as producers and songwriters. If every one of those dozens of nominated collaborators had had a few friends in the Academy who voted for it, it should have been a shoo-in for rap album.
—With reporting by Shirley Halperin and Ellise Shafer
