As the fall draws to a close, and the late night talk shows still adjust to their post-strike rhythm (and one host in particular navigates some unexpected health crises), there appears to now be a steady ratings story to be told in live+same day numbers. In adults 18-49, ABC’s “Jimmy Kimmel Live” is emerging as the No. 1 talk show in that key demo, while CBS’ “The Late Show with Stephen Colbert” is tops in total viewers. (Time shifted numbers benefit Colbert the most, however, as he leads in both measurements when it comes to “live+most current” numbers. Scroll down for those figures.)
Boosted this season by the return of NFL Monday Night Football to ABC’s full time lineup, “Jimmy Kimmel Live” is so far up 13 percent in total viewers and has pulled off its most-watched fall since 2020, according to ABC. Among adults 18-49 in live+same day, “Jimmy Kimmel Live” is first in the demo with originals, averaging a 0.20, followed by “The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon” (0.18) and “The Late Show with Stephen Colbert” (0.15).
“The Late Show” aired fewer episodes this fall, as Colbert was out for a week due to COVID-19, and then out again more recently for several weeks due to a ruptured appendix. However, in originals, Colbert was still tops with total viewers (1.88 million), followed by Kimmel (1.68 million) and Fallon (1.31 million).
“Late Night with Seth Meyers” posted a 0.11 in the 18-49 demo, and 792,000, in its later hour.
A reminder that these are linear, live+same day numbers only, between Oct. 2 (when the shows all returned post-strike) and Dec. 10. With so much viewing of late night now online, it’s tougher to properly gauge the popularity of late night in 2023. But this is at least a first measuring stick to the long tail.
When live+most current numbers are used — which includes time shifted live+7 ratings (Oct. 2 to Dec. 6) and live+3 (Dec. 7 to Dec. 8) — Colbert pulls further ahead. When repeats are not included, “The Late Show” is first in viewers with 2.66 million, followed by “Jimmy Kimmel Live” (1.91 million) and “Tonight Show” (1.42 million). In adults 18-49, Colbert also squeaks ahead with 286,000 viewers in the demo vs. Kimmel’s 280,000 and Fallon’s 246,000.
The late night space is about to enter an election year, where the fate of the American democracy appears to be on the line. The daypart is also about to see changes at “The Daily Show,” which is expected to announce a permanent replacement for Trevor Noah (who exited a year ago this month), as well as in the late-late night slot at CBS, where “The Late Late Show” is about to be replaced by the panel series “After Midnight,” hosted by Taylor Tomlinson.
